Peter's Gallery :: World War II - Combat (Dell) 12, April-June 1964

Combat 12, page 15 by Sam Glanzman

Artists: Sam Glanzman (Penciller) , Sam Glanzman (Inker)

11 Comments - 408 Views - 7 Likes

Combat 12, page 15 by Sam Glanzman Comic Art

Click Image to View Full Size

Additional Images:

Published page

Previous Item:
Combat 12, page 14 by Sam Glanzman

Next Item:
Combat 12, page 17 by Sam Glanzman

Artwork Details

Title:	Combat 12, page 15 by Sam Glanzman
Artist:	Sam Glanzman (Penciller)
Artist:	Sam Glanzman (Inker)
Media Type:	Pen and Ink
Art Type:	Interior Page
For Sale Status:	NFS
Views:	408
Likes on CAF:	7 8
Comments:	11
Added to Site:	9/5/2025
Comic Art Archive:	Combat Issue: 12 Page: 15 View

Description

"Guadalcanal" by Paul S. Newman. April-June 1964.

This account of the patrol deviates quite a bit from what actually happened during this poorly planned and executed reconnaissance mission.

Although the comic says the leader was a captain, the patrol was led by the First Marine Division's intelligence chief, Lt. Col. Goettge. He proposed and pushed for, as well as insisted on leading, the mission. The commanding general approved the mission but didn't want him to lead it, but after some discussion relented, according to a US Naval Institute article (full reference at the end of the description).

The plan called for them to land in the daylight, conduct reconnaissance, and return overland the next day. Goettge was warned that rescue or relief was unlikely if they ran into trouble. He disregarded concerns raised by others and the lateness of the hour, pushing what was intended to be a daylight landing into the night.

As the landing craft headed in, Goettge ignored the prisoner's warning that they were in the wrong area. The comic is accurate that the landing craft's noise alerted the Japanese naval guard unit. That noise, however, also included efforts to free the craft after running aground while landing.

Firing didn't start with the men on the beach but when Goettge and two others approached the village scouting for a place to spend the night. Goettge was indeed immediately killed, but the prisoner wasn't with him or killed by enemy fire. A platoon sergeant at the beach shot and killed the prisoner when shooting started. A survivor remembers seeing the platoon sergeant on the landing craft holding the line that was attached to the neck of the Japanese seaman and saying "if anything happens, he�ll be the first to get it.�

Source: "The Goettge Patrol" by Lieutenant Colonel J. N. Mueller, December 1992, Naval History, Volume 6, Number 4
https://www.usni.org/magazines/naval-history-magazine/1992/december/goettge-patrol

Social/Sharing

About the Owner

	Peter Roe ( 1 ) Premium Gallery Owner
Joined:	February 2009
Last Login:	September 2025
Country:	UNITED STATES
On CAF:	Peter's Classifieds Peter's Want List Artworks Commented On Liked Art Site Activity on CAF

Contact the Owner

Use can use a contact form to send an email to this gallery owner,
but, you must be logged in to use this feature.

Comments on this Artwork

You must be logged in to make comments.

Ruben DaCollector
Member Since 2008

1 - Posted on 9/5/2025

The 3rd panel is beautiful. So is the 4th one, but it immediately gave me flashbacks to the opening scene in Saving Private Ryan, which makes me whince!

Peter Roe
Member Since 2009

1 - Posted on 9/5/2025

Ruben DaCollector wrote:

The 3rd panel is beautiful. So is the 4th one, but it immediately gave me flashbacks to the opening scene in Saving Private Ryan, which makes me whince!

Thanks, Rubén. I like Sam's storytelling layout here and off-kilter perspective in the second panel. The last panel is indeed quite impactful. I probably mentioned this before, but I can't rewatch Saving Private Ryan because its opening and closing scenes are so graphic and heart-rending. It's like you are in the battle being shot at. On the other hand, the dialogue and scenes in the middle of the movie struck me as contrived, writing school stuff, further discouraging me from a second viewing.

Tom McDonald
Member Since 2019

1 - Posted on 9/5/2025

Peter Roe wrote:

Thanks, Rub�n. I like Sam's storytelling layout here and off-kilter perspective in the second panel. The last panel is indeed quite impactful. I probably mentioned this before, but I can't�rewatch Saving Private Ryan because its opening and closing scenes are so graphic and heart-rending. It's like you are in the battle being shot at. On the other hand, the dialogue and scenes in the middle of the movie struck me as contrived, writing school stuff, further discouraging me from a second viewing.�

Although I don’t have Peter's encyclopedic knowledge of WWII, I have read a lot. I visited the Normandy Beaches twice and Bastogne twice, including for the 60th anniversary memorial ceremony of the “Battle of the Bulge” in 2004 (which Tom Hanks also attended).

I visited the Normandy Beaches about a month before “Saving Private Ryan” was released. After returning from a business trip that Friday, I went straight from the airport to the film's final showing at a local theatre (I did that for Batman vs. Superman too). I could not believe what I had just seen. I could not sleep, so I read about D-Day all night, then attended the first showing the following day. The opening scene was far more difficult to watch after having read all night.

I don’t think I have seen the movie since.

Peter Roe
Member Since 2009

Posted on 9/6/2025

Peter Roe wrote:

Correction. Off-kilter perspective is the third panel.

Peter Roe
Member Since 2009

Posted on 9/6/2025

Tom McDonald wrote:

Although I don�t have Peter's encyclopedic knowledge of WWII, I have read a lot.�I visited the Normandy Beaches twice and�Bastogne twice, including for the 60th anniversary memorial ceremony of the �Battle of the Bulge� in 2004 (which Tom Hanks also attended).

I visited the Normandy Beaches about a month before �Saving Private Ryan� was released. After returning from a business trip that Friday, I went straight from the airport to the film's final showing at a local theatre (I did that for Batman vs. Superman too). I could not believe what I had just seen. I could not sleep, so I �read about D-Day all night, then attended the first showing the following day. The opening scene was far more difficult to watch after having read all night.

I don�t think I have seen the movie since.

Thanks, Tom! Wow! Great comment! I would like to see Bastogne. Amazing time for you to be there with so many veterans plus Tom Hanks! Seeing Normandy is sobering; I was there a few years earlier in 1997. I can't imagine seeing the movie several weeks after visiting Normandy, reading about D-Day all night, and seeing it again in the morning! I couldn't do that! I saw the film in a large theater in China with Mandarin subtitles.

Marcus Wai
Member Since 2005

1 - Posted on 9/5/2025

How can they trust a prisoner with real information? The center panel is very strong with the machine gun and its firepower cutting through the background of the brush. The bottom panel is a massacre in the making!

Peter Roe
Member Since 2009

1 - Posted on 9/5/2025

Marcus Wai wrote:

How can they trust a prisoner with real information?� The center panel is very strong with the machine gun and its firepower cutting through the background of the brush.� The bottom panel is a massacre in the making!

Thanks, Marcus! Excellent question. From the US Naval Institute article: "He (sic the prisoner) was somewhat emaciated, and that lent credence to his statements. His account was further strengthened by similar accounts received from recently captured Korean laborers from the same area. It is unlikely that he deliberately set out to deceive his captors." It's unknown why Goettge didn't trust the prisoner about the landing site when the prisoner's other statements had been corroborated to the point of risking soldiers' lives in a reconnaissance patrol.

Kavi H
Member Since 2018

1 - Posted on 9/5/2025

another great page! to me that bottom panel (in isolation or in context) may be the strongest image I can recall in a war comic I've seen in quite some time. excellent (and horrifying).

Miki Annamanthadoo
Member Since 2003

2 - Posted on 9/5/2025

Kavi H wrote:

another great page! to me that bottom panel (in isolation or in context) may be the strongest image I can recall in a war comic I've seen in quite some time. excellent (and horrifying).�

War is brutal!

John C
Member Since 2014

1 - Posted on 9/5/2025

The best defense is a good defense.

Peter Roe
Member Since 2009

1 - Posted on 9/5/2025

John C wrote:

The best defense is a good defense.

Dudley Moore and Eddie Murphy

All
	Nikolaos K 9/7/2025 11:47:00 AM
	Michael One Minute Later 9/7/2025 11:38:00 AM
	eric Kazatsky 9/7/2025 11:23:00 AM
	Ali Mourad 9/7/2025 11:18:00 AM
	mr. wolfie 9/7/2025 11:16:00 AM
View All


	brett wood 9/7/2025 11:06:00 AM
	Will Gabri-El 9/7/2025 10:50:00 AM
	Stephen F 9/7/2025 10:43:00 AM
	Athenaeum Comic Art 9/7/2025 10:24:00 AM
	Miki Annamanthadoo 9/7/2025 10:22:00 AM