Ruben DaCollector wrote:
" This is a very strong page from the period during which Smith (He hadn't been credited in print as "Windsor-" at this point, hence why I leave it out) was quickly developing his abilities which would ultimately peak with issue #24 and the Red Nails story. Sal did a very creditable job with the inks indeed and the page exhibits a very nice variety of both Conan and Elric images.
I'm not going to pretend I know who these people are that you often mention are talking about how much you often overpay for art, but I can certainly tell you that most people who opine on such things just want to feel that others see them as knowledgeable, as that makes them feel as if they are "respected" and/or "important" collectors. In reality, most don't even understand how much more nuance there is to evaluating any given piece of comic art. The reality of THIS situation is that art values across the board have been consistently rising rapidly and non-stop since the advent of the World Wide Web. From 2017 to 2020, this page would realistically already have risen and extra $2k to $4k, fairly leaving it settle at around $14k-$15k. From 2020 to 2023 alone, most mainstream art rose anywhere from 2x to 5x. Some even a lot more than that, and some a little bit less. But even if Barry Smith Conan art softened a little bit over the past couple of years, the very first appearance of Elric (in this case, the very first page that birthed him into mainstream comics) would be the exception to the rule and would not soften along with all the other pages. In fact, the key appearance factor would mean it would be expected to continue rising as all important key character appearances have continued to do. Conan not being a superhero, of course, I would not expect THIS piece to have risen by 5x side by side with much Spidey and X-Men related art. But a 2x rise by the time late 2025 rolled around? Of course that should be expected, and if you've been doing the math as I've gone along here, the price you paid is slightly less than $3k short of that 2x price rise. So you paid what is essentially around the FMV for this piece in 2025.
This is not simply a key page because it features the birth of a character, but rather its importance lies in the fact that many readers of comics, both during the early 70's and even still today, were Fantasy/Sword & Sorcery novel readers and Michael Moorcock was and still remains today a very popular writer in that genre. He is the creator of Elric and the character had already been extremely popular in print for a decade by the time he made his appearance on this page.
So, for whatever it's worth, my advice is to just stop listening to or reading the opinions of those who know far less than YOU do about comic art values and who certainly don't have their fingers on the pulse of this hobby/market the way you do. Enjoy this amazing and important piece!
"
Many thanks as always, Rubén, for your exceedingly kind and encouraging words, as well as for your characteristically perceptive analyses.
It is also true that I had forgotten that many persons have read as well as enjoyed Michael Moorcock's novels.
At the end of the day, though, I just want to enjoy this hobby, exercising as much financial prudence as is possible, especially during this era of ever rising prices. This may appear to be more than a tad idealistic but, given what is going on in the world today, perhaps a little bit of idealism isn't wholly out of place.