1934.07.03 “Fine Words Butter No Parsnips”
by Milton Rawson Halladay (1874-1961)
15 x 16 in., ink on board
Coppola Collection
Halladay was a native of Vermont and a noted political cartoonist for the Providence Journal (Rhode Island) for nearly fifty years (1900-1947). His cartoons were published in countless other newspapers and magazines. He has been called "one of the deans of American political cartooning." His cartoon commemorating the death of Thomas A. Edison was a runner-up for the Pulitzer Prize.
This proverbial saying is English and dates from the 17th century. It expresses the notion that fine words count for nothing and that action means more than flattery or promises.
During the First New Deal period (1933–34), business leaders grew increasingly frustrated with what they saw as unfulfilled promises: the National Recovery Act (NRA) codes, public works programs, and regulatory expansion frustrated many in the business community.
Labor unrest raised concerns about New Deal impact on business stability. Editorials by conservative outlets and business-aligned commentators warned that Roosevelt’s verbal assurances were not enough—that action was needed to restore business confidence.
In FDR’s Fireside Chat on June 28, 1934, he acknowledged mounting criticism and addressed business leaders directly. He reaffirmed the administration’s commitment, but the tone acknowledged that promises alone weren’t enough. Editorial comment reflected the sentiment that action was needed.
