Gallery Comments by R Shur

Owner:

shaun clancy

I like thi smore than the original :hide

Owner:

shaun clancy

This what recreations are all about!

The 1978 original is in my gallery. Glad to see at least 2 of us are huge fans of this Pollard Cap & 1st* Peggy Carter cover.
 

Owner:

Interesting page

Owner:

Gary Land

Suspended pain, I cannot face the black flame
Intended fear, I cannot trace the black flame
Extended, reaching into space, the black flame
Burns my blackened brain
-  Michael Dunford, Betty Thatcher

Owner:

Stone Cold Classic Issue - featured in the original "Marvel's Greatest Super-Hero battles"

Owner:

Ben Bressel

Oh Man! I won that Tom Mandrake Batman Cover way back then.  Sure does not seem like 24 years ago...but it is...

Thanks for posting this as I never saved the Catalog.

BTW I still own the cover :) :
https://www.comicartfans.com/gallerypiece.asp?piece=8235

Owner:

* bronze-is-gold

Classic SA Age Atom!  Even if its in a Bronze Age dated comic

Owner:

Congrats on your special piece.

Welcome to the Trimpe Godzilla Splash Club!

Owner:

Dillan was so under-rated. This page is an example of that.  

I have a page from the sequence as well: https://www.comicartfans.com/gallerypiece.asp?piece=1441046

Owner:

So nice to see a page from my first childhood DC Comic

Owner:

Very nice!!!

Owner:

Excellent unbpublished pencils recaping the also unpublished Steel #6.

Owner:

Richard Morgan

Love the 'dawg!

Manning did really nice H-B work.  So too did Paul Norris on Dynomutt

Owner:

Rare Marvel with McLaughlin inks. Never saw his over Sal pencils before, they look nice.

Owner:

Wayne Mousseau

Brenda and Eddie were the popular steadies

Owner:

T Dann

Wow, I love this Sal/Joe page!

Owner:

Rich Cirillo

Receiving a comment from the Main Man Marcus on art you created yourself means you have truly made it in the eyes of CAF royalty.

Owner:

Dan M.

Ostranders's and Mandrakes's Court Sequence in #55 was outstanding.  So much so that the one I have is a very rare post mid 80s peice in my collection.

The issue reminds me a lot of the Adventure Spectre's!

Owner:

Dave W

I owned this Sal Hulk splash for several years in the 00's. I do miss it. But sometimes you have to trade something to get something.  

Owner:

Lloyd White

No Cuckoos Nest reference from me...

Bryant has become a forgotton inker but did very slick work.  Bair is far too underated by art collectors.

Owner:

Richard Morgan

Every cover with the Coyote on it is A Good Cover!

Owner:

Peter Roe

Love Maurer's work. Was lucky to find a piece myself many years ago.

Owner:

Shannon Weathers

This page and those like it exemplify the great Dylan/McLaughlin JLA Era

Owner:

Ted Latner

Update:
I was informed recently that a few years ago CGC corrected in on their slab labels.  CBCS always had it correct as Sienkiewicz. 

Bill Sienkiewicz signed it for me in Oct 2025 and told me it was great to see it again after those many years :)

Owner:

Daren Domina

The Nose Era!

Owner:

Those early Romita Jr/Layton IM pages are just as slick now as they were back then!  You can FEEL the impact in the forth panel.

IMHO just as special as circa 1979 Byrne/Austin even if I'm not in the majority with that opinion :)

Owner:

Brian Peck

You can tell Jerry loved these pages with all the ink on Grundy and Degaton

3rd Panel has "bothered" me since 1981 :) Here's the thing...In the preview issue (3-4 months prior) Powerful Super-Humans Wonder Woman, Green Lantern and the Flash are like tiny gnats to Grundy, but here Dr Midnight with his average human strength, takes him out with a single punch.

Totally absurd!  Thats akin to Daredevil doing the same to the Abomination or the Ted Cord Blue Beetle doing that to Doomsday.

Good to get that off my chest.

Owner:

Dan F

Gold Key goodness!

That sure is

Owner:

Rich Cirillo

Wow that's striking! You made the right choice.

Owner:

Zaddick L

KILLRAVEN!
 

Very Slick Russell

Owner:

Alex Johnson

So cool and Groo would not stand a chance against Sugar

Owner:

Marcus Wai

1st !

Owner:

Tanghal had a nice looking run on WWT as evidenced by this page and others.

Owner:

Wow and Welcome Aboard Tom!

Owner:

Why is this fine page listed as NSF (Not Safe for Work) ?

Owner:

Phenomenal First Panel!

Owner:

George Hagenauer

That is some Smooth looking Sci-Fi!

Owner:

Brian Peck

Gonzales deserves much more respect that the Original Comic Art community gives him!

Owner:

Lloyd White

Fantastic 'zilla

Trimpe must have relished drawing big green
 

Owner:

Max Raskin

Sometimes a single panel page can "best" an entire 25 year collection like mine, this is one of those times. Wow!

Owner:

WOW!!!

Slight nitpick; In artists field it should be Keith, not Kieth

Owner:

Wow! Giella's inks on this page allows the image to comfortably flow.

Owner:

Hi Steve,

I've owned this cover since 2008;

https://www.comicartfans.com/GalleryPiece.asp?Piece=444838

I hoping that you will please consider removing it from your gallery.  Thanks!

Owner:

Ted Latner

Nice!

Do you have in a "Floatin frame" so both sides can be viewed?

Thanks for posting it after all these years. Glad to see I'm not only one who first now posts acquisitions from 15-24 years back :)

Owner:

Ted Latner

What's funny now is that I bought this off eBay in 2007 and was the only bidder, probably because this was seen as a "boring" overpriced epilogue page that came at the end of a great....

I do so miss those days :)

Owner:

Zaddick L

C'est incroyable!

Owner:

Dan F

Lulu is timeless. More folks should give reading the 1950s-mid 60s stuff a chance!

Owner:

Great sense of motion on Subby's dive!  Layton slick inks are outstanding. I think it would have been very interesting had he been the one inking Infantino on Nova

Owner:

Love the Sarge. Nice Ayers/Shores Spash.

Owner:

Nice one!

Please note: inks on your page are by Dick Giodano who did JLA 107-109-109 not Frank McLaughlin. Also apolgies for one more tiny nitpick its Dillin not Dillon - I've made the same error myself many times :)