Log In Register
Jonathan Nathan UNITED STATES
Member Since January 2012
0 Artworks | Watched by 0

Gallery Comments by Jonathan Nathan

13 Results

Batman #S-4607, Comic Art
Batman #S-4607
Owner:
commented posted on 7/31/2025

No, I'm almost certain this wasn't published. I have seen other pages from it and it seems like a pretty wild two-part "imaginary story" or "it was all a dream" thing.

Flash Comics #?? (DC Comics 1948-49-ish) - Black Canary by Carmine Infantino - Published (years later) in DC Special #3 (June 1969) , Comic Art
Flash Comics #?? (DC Comics 1948-49-ish) - Black Canary by Carmine Infantino - Published (years later) in DC Special #3 (June 1969)
Owner:
commented posted on 9/9/2021
Michael One Minute Later said:

Thank you - I will update now.  Many thank for the information.

I'm afraid I must humbly ask forgiveness: I was incorrect. The story was published in DC Special #3 (June 1969) and was called "Special Delivery Death."

Cloak and Dagger #1 (Fox 1940-something) -- Golden Age -- unpublished???, Comic Art
Cloak and Dagger #1 (Fox 1940-something) -- Golden Age -- unpublished???
Owner:
commented posted on 9/6/2021
Michael One Minute Later said:

No - not at all.....most but not all - I just never have time.

I'd be very interested to know what else you have. If you ever get the chance to catalog it or take photos/scans, please let me know.

Cloak and Dagger #1 (Fox 1940-something) -- Golden Age -- unpublished???, Comic Art
Cloak and Dagger #1 (Fox 1940-something) -- Golden Age -- unpublished???
Owner:
commented posted on 9/6/2021
Michael One Minute Later said:

I have lots of unpublished GA material - will be interested in your blog and what you have to say.  

Is it all posted to CAF?

Cloak and Dagger #1 (Fox 1940-something) -- Golden Age -- unpublished???, Comic Art
Cloak and Dagger #1 (Fox 1940-something) -- Golden Age -- unpublished???
Owner:
commented posted on 9/6/2021

I was all set to leave a comment with information about this, but I actually think I've raised more questions. Definitely going to write about this at my blog when it goes live.

Doctor Mid-Nite Tier - All American Comics #110 (DC 1949) - Top Tier, Comic Art
Doctor Mid-Nite Tier - All American Comics #110 (DC 1949) - Top Tier
Owner:
commented posted on 9/6/2021
Michael One Minute Later said:

Once again, Jonathan, I am in your debt.  Thank you for the great information.  Most appreciated.

To be clear, it was never published so far as I know. In fact the only one of these unpublished Golden Age stories that I've seen evidence of having eventually been published is that Black Canary one.

Golden age Green Lantern, Comic Art
Golden age Green Lantern
Owner:
commented posted on 9/6/2021

This is from "The Secret of Happy Valley"! I've seen all three tiers separately before, but not put together. How did you figure out they went together? Anyway, I've only ever seen this story attributed to Hasen.

Giffen - Lobo Unpublished Page, Comic Art
Giffen - Lobo Unpublished Page
Owner:
commented posted on 9/6/2021

Where did you hear about the origins of this page? From what I know, the "too violent" Lobo story you mention was drawn by Bill Wray.

Doctor Mid-Nite Tier - All American Comics #110 (DC 1949) - Top Tier, Comic Art
Doctor Mid-Nite Tier - All American Comics #110 (DC 1949) - Top Tier
Owner:
commented posted on 9/5/2021

I've seen two tiers from this story. Not connected to this one, but they're both from what would have been All-American Comics #110.

Flash Comics #?? (DC Comics 1948-49-ish) - Black Canary by Carmine Infantino - Published (years later) in DC Special #3 (June 1969) , Comic Art
Flash Comics #?? (DC Comics 1948-49-ish) - Black Canary by Carmine Infantino - Published (years later) in DC Special #3 (June 1969)
Owner:
commented posted on 9/5/2021

This one was eventually published decades later in Adventure Comics #399. The title is "Television Told The Tale."

Green Lantern (DC Comics 1940x) - Alex Toth - unpublished, Comic Art
Green Lantern (DC Comics 1940x) - Alex Toth - unpublished
Owner:
commented posted on 9/5/2021

I'm actually working on a post about this story for a blog that hasn't gone live yet. For one thing, every source I've seen lists it as being by Infantino, although looking at it I can see how someone would think Toth. In fact, on a whim I just did a little googling and lo and behold, a tier I hadn't seen before turns up on Heritage Auctions, attributed to Toth. I don't think anyone knows for sure who drew it, but what I can tell you is that it's from the same story as your 2/3 page (which you attribute to Infantino) in the same gallery. The story was slated for publication in Green Lantern #39, but the title was canceled after #38.

All-Star Comics #?? (DC Comics 1945) -
All-Star Comics #?? (DC Comics 1945) - "The WIll of William Wilson" - Green Lantern by Paul Reinman
Owner:
commented posted on 9/5/2021

Is TwoMorrows Publishing aware of this tier? They've been trying to piece this story together for decades, and this tier fills a gap (at least as of the last I knew, circa All-Star Companion 3. Haven't gotten around to picking up the fourth volume yet.)

Curt Swan Unpublished Batman Story, Comic Art
Curt Swan Unpublished Batman Story
Owner:
commented posted on 4/15/2013

If I bake you a cake, will you share the rest of the story?