ADVERTISEMENT
Welcome to ComicArtFans!

Scherberger, What If? The New FF #1 cover

Artist: Patrick Scherberger (Penciller)

11 Comments  -   1,466 Views  -   0 Like


Scherberger, What If?  The New FF #1 cover Comic Art
Click Image to View Full Size

 

Additional Images:


What If? New FF #1

 

   

Artwork Details

Title: Scherberger, What If? The New FF #1 cover
Artist: Patrick Scherberger (Penciller)
Media Type: Pencil
Art Type: Cover
For Sale Status: traded
Views: 1,466
Likes on CAF:
0
Comments: 11
Added to Site: 5/12/2012
Comic Art Archive:

Description

ACQUISITION DATE: 2012
SOURCE: dealer
OWNER HISTORY: 1
DIMENSIONS: 11x17
STOCK: bristol
CREATION DATE: n/a
SIGNATURE: “PS”
PUBLICATION: Feb. 2009


If I were a working comic book artist, this is the kind of thing that would almost make me cry! You knock yourself out penciling a kick ass cover and turn it in hoping that when it’s digitally inked and colored, the computer enhancements will do your piece justice. Then you see THIS (see Additional Images) on the stands! WTF????? The digital inks, and especially the digital coloring, make all the figures look like marshmallow people? LOL! Oh well, at least I have the original pencils.

Ever since I picked up my first two Scherberger pieces, I’ve been jonesing for more! I love Patrick’s work, but it’s not exactly cheap, so I had to bide my time until I either had enough money or (as was the case with my first purchase) Spencer had a sale on his website. After I bought my first two covers, Patrick told me he was considering another sale during the holidays. That never materialized, but an even bigger sale finally did.

I was at work one day when I got an email from my bro Jonathan telling me about Spencer’s and Patrick’s sale. I immediately went to the website, where I fell in love with this cover. And of course the sale price made it that much more irresistible.

Anyway, this is the pencil cover art for WHAT IF? NEW FANTASTIC FOUR #1. Would’ve been nice to throw up an Avengers related piece to honor the success of Joss Whedon’s juggernaut blockbuster film, but I guess having the Hulk and Iron Man on this cover will have to do. Funny how so many versions and variations of the team have come about over the years. You expect all the roster changes from the Avengers, but not the FF. Yet when you look back over the team‘s history, there have been plenty of noteworthy “guest” members! She Hulk, Luke Cage, Medusa, to name a few. And of course the incredible lineup that featured Wolverine, Spidey, Hulk, and Ghost Rider, from the classic Walt Simonson / Art Adams story arc.

This latest variation finds Iron Man stepping in for Ghost Rider, but with Patrick’s playful, cartoony, style; the team is just as much fun to look at (as long as you’re not looking at the published cover, that is). While I loved it when Patrick finally began to ink himself, I think his pencil work is every bit as fun AND brilliant. Also nice to see him tackle characters other than Spider-man (great job on Iron Man here), although Spidey is still my favorite character that he draws!

Anyway, thanks Spencer and Patrick! Can’t wait to add even more Scherberger art to my collection!

Social/Sharing


About the Owner

E DLS ( 3 )
Premium Gallery Owner
Joined: March 2005
Last Login: September 2025
Country: UNITED STATES
On CAF:

Premium Member Q&A
E's Classifieds
E's Want List
Artworks Commented On
Liked Art
Site Activity on CAF

Read More About EDLS

Contact the Owner

Use can use a contact form to send an email to this gallery owner,
but, you must be logged in to use this feature.



Comments on this Artwork

You must be logged in to make comments.

Danny Morales 
Member Since 2005

Posted on 5/12/2012

Awesome cover!

Will K 
Member Since 2006

Posted on 5/12/2012

I would say the color job is consistent with Marvel's T+ rating.

E DLS 
Member Since 2005

Posted on 5/13/2012

Will K wrote:

I would say the color job is consistent with Marvel's T+ rating.

Yeah, "T" as in TERRIBLE! LOL! Of course I only refer to the coloring. The pencils are AWESOME!!!!!

aric shapiro 
Member Since 2006

Posted on 5/14/2012

Some of the best pencils I've seen! INCREDIBLE!!!

- Artemaria 
Member Since 2007

Posted on 5/14/2012

Scherberger's pencils are indeed "fantastic" and are therefore quite appropriate for this little grouping. As for your description's references to the published version, I agree, all of the heroes look like they just got off the Atkins diet and went straight for the pizzeria, or are auditioning for the role of a certain French tire pitchman. However, in its own way, the published cover is extremely effective for its titled series - "what if," such as what if the cover was inked more crisply, or colored more effectively. These glorious pencils make us long for such "what ifs." Congratulations on a great cover my friend!

E DLS 
Member Since 2005

Posted on 5/14/2012

- Artemaria wrote:

Scherberger's pencils are indeed "fantastic" and are therefore quite appropriate for this little grouping. As for your description's references to the published version, I agree, all of the heroes look like they just got off the Atkins diet and went straight for the pizzeria, or are auditioning for the role of a certain French tire pitchman. However, in its own way, the published cover is extremely effective for its titled series - "what if," such as what if the cover was inked more crisply, or colored more effectively. These glorious pencils make us long for such "what ifs." Congratulations on a great cover my friend!

Ha! I love it. The possibilities for alternate titles are endless! What if? The coloring didn't suck? What If? They hired someone who actually knew how to use a computer? What if? They used a person who actually knew what these characters looked like? Thanks Artemis, you crack me up buddy!

Nelson Animated Ink 
Member Since 2005

Posted on 5/16/2012

It's a nice fun cover. I love his pencils and can't wait to see what else you picked up. Cheers! N.

Kris Justice 
Member Since 2007

Posted on 5/23/2012

Looks great, you should maybe get it inked though.

E DLS 
Member Since 2005

Posted on 5/23/2012

Kris Justice wrote:

Looks great, you should maybe get it inked though.

While I admit to being curious as to how it would look inked, I am more than happy with this pencil version. Of course if Patrick himself ever got the bug to do an inked version over blueline, I would also be happy to take that off his hands! =)

Thomas V 
Member Since 2008

Posted on 5/26/2012

I'm blown away by the disconnect between the pencils and the published version. I don't know if I've ever seen an artist so altered by a colorist before.

Michael Henderson 
Member Since 2008

Posted on 5/27/2012

I love Patrick's work, his style stands out among many other artists. His spidey is one of the best. Nice piece.

Latest Updates

All

Nikolaos K

9/7/2025 11:00:00 AM

eric Kazatsky

9/7/2025 10:55:00 AM

Will Gabri-El

9/7/2025 10:50:00 AM

Stephen F

9/7/2025 10:43:00 AM

Athenaeum Comic Art

9/7/2025 10:24:00 AM

 

Miki Annamanthadoo

9/7/2025 10:22:00 AM

CW Roelle

9/7/2025 10:19:00 AM

Stuart Lawrence

9/7/2025 9:59:00 AM

Rick Verbanas

9/7/2025 9:50:00 AM

Wade AuCoin

9/7/2025 9:41:00 AM

eBay Auctions ADVERTISEMENT

"Jim Bob and the Alien" original art mag illustration Aboriginal S

Heritage Auctions

Rick Leonardi and Jimmy Palmiotti Alpha Flight #18

ComicLink Auctions

TODD MCFARLANE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #316 PAGE 18 (GREAT PETER/MJ PAGE WITH VENOM!)

Comic Connect Auctions

Tom Lyle - Amazing Spider-Man #431 Cover - Silver Surfer as Cosmic Carnage!

Hakes Auctions

STAR WARS #5 COMIC BOOK PAGE ORIGINAL ART BY HOWARD CHAYKIN.
















Subscribe to the YouTube Channel.. FREE!




Featured Art Rep
TDArt Gallery Logo TDArt Gallery
26 Repped Artists
12 Accepting Commissions
Blake
Grove
Johnson
Simanson
Toland-Scott
McKee

 

Commission an Artist


For Sale Updates

Classified Updates

Nikolaos K

9/7/2025 11:00:00 AM

Will Gabri-El

9/7/2025 10:50:00 AM

Athenaeum  Comic Art

9/7/2025 10:24:00 AM

Rick Verbanas

9/7/2025 9:50:00 AM

Peter Venkman

9/7/2025 9:25:00 AM

*  HoxtonArcade

9/7/2025 6:48:00 AM

Dealer Updates

Will's Comic Art Page

9/7/2025 10:50:00 AM

RomitaMan Original Art

9/7/2025 2:23:00 AM

NSN Art

9/7/2025 12:01:00 AM

TDArt Gallery

9/6/2025 7:54:00 PM

Anthony's Comicbook Art

9/6/2025 3:57:00 PM

Coollines Artwork

9/6/2025 3:28:00 PM





Become a Premium CAF Gallery Owner & you'll be supporting CAF and also gain access to many services and features not available to standard members.

  • Sell Artwork in the CAF Classifieds
  • Daily Email Alerts based on your own Searches
  • Follow Other Gallery Owners
  • 6 Months Market Data Access
  • Larger Image Uploads ... and Much More!