Julien K GERMANY
Member Since August 2017
115 Artworks | Watched by 30

Johnny Craig & John Romita Sr. - Tower Of Shadows #1 Pg 6

Location: For sale/trade
Artists: Johnny Craig (All) ,  John Romita Sr. (All)

1528  Views  -  2  Comments  -  5  Likes

Additional Images

Holding it against the light helps to get a glimpse of Craig‘s original art

Tower Of Shadows #4 letters page explaining the assistance of John Romita Sr.

Published Page For Reference
Artwork Details
Location: For sale/trade
Title: Johnny Craig & John Romita Sr. - Tower Of Shadows #1 Pg 6
Artist:  Johnny Craig (All) ,  John Romita Sr. (All)
Media Type: Pen and Ink
Art Type: Interior Page
For Sale Status: USD 3299
Views: 1528
Likes on CAF: 5
Comments: 2
Added to Site: 11/21/2022

Share This Artwork
Description
10 3/4"x 15 3/4"

Interior page from „Tower of Shadows“ #1 (1969), story called „From Beyond The Brink!“.
Johnny Craig did the art for this story, but when Stan Lee was disappointed with the appearance of Craig's characters (particularly the attractiveness of the female) he had John Romita Sr. draw new faces, which were carefully pasted over Craig's art. The paste-ups are all original art. Check additional picture to see Johnny Craig‘s original art underneath some of those paste-ups. The top right panel was completely re-drawn by Romita.

Romita's role in that story has been covered in many places:

- here's an article with a quote from Mark Evanier: https://pappysgoldenage.blogspot.com/2009/02/number-468-touched-and-retouched-i-knew.html

- Romita's role was acknowledged by Marvel in the letters page to "Tower Of Shadows" #4 (see attached picture): https://errors.comics.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5453

- the Grand Comic Database (comics.org) lists the credits as Craig with Romita alterations: https://www.comics.org/issue/22978/


Thanks to Jeremy Radisich!


About The Owner

Thank You For Supporting CAF!
Julien K
Badges: Premium Gallery Owner Best of 2021
Member Since: August 2017
Last Login: April 2026
Country: GERMANY
On CAF:
Julien's Classifieds
Artworks Commented On
Liked Art
Site Activity
Contact Julien K

Login or register for an account to email the owner of this artwork.

Comments on this Artwork

You must be logged in to make comments.
Mark Yanko Member Since 2009
1    
Posted On 11/22/2022

This is just totally cringe-inducing. Literally every face on the page was deemed to be so unworthy of Marvel by Stan Lee that it was necessary to redraw it completely? What an insult to an artist of Craig's stature. One can only imagine with horror how Craig, by all accounts an unassuming man, must've felt  when he saw this. How bad could it all have been, by any stretch of the imagination?

Julien K Member Since 2017
Posted On 11/22/2022

Mark Yanko wrote:
"  This is just totally cringe-inducing. Literally every face on the page was deemed to be so unworthy of Marvel by Stan Lee that it was necessary to redraw it completely? What an insult to an artist of Craig's stature. One can only imagine with horror how Craig, by all accounts an unassuming man, must've felt  when he saw this. How bad could it all have been, by any stretch of the imagination?
 "

I agree, very disrespectful towards Johnny. While Romita's ability to draw beautiful women surpasses that of Johnny Craig, it was Craigs story after all.