Plunkett, Robert :: Misc Published Pages III

Toth or Not(h) Romance Page

Artist: Nobody Knows (All)

9 Comments - 2,353 Views - 0 Like

Previous Item:
Lightning Lass Splash by The Moys

Next Item:
Shaffenberger Supes and Yellow Peri

Artwork Details

Title:	Toth or Not(h) Romance Page
Artist:	Nobody Knows (All)
Media Type:	Pen and Ink
Art Type:	Interior Page
For Sale Status:	For Sale, please make offer or inquire
Views:	2,353
Likes on CAF:	0 1
Comments:	9
Added to Site:	8/8/2007
Comic Art Archive:

Description

This is Page 9 of Secret Hearts #145. Several things in it make me think it may be at least partially by Alex Toth. As near as I can tell, the sources that pass judgment on this don't weigh in on this particular story. Toth indisputably worked on Secret Hearts as close as #143. The experts I've shown it to think it's close or to close to call. One said he thought Toth may have penciled it and someone else inked it. Feel free to weigh in on this one.

Since I posted the above invitation, I got input both here and from the Comicart-L group. In contrast to those who saw the page in person at SDCC, everybody on line was firm that it wasn't Toth. As for those with an opinion as to who it was instead, I got the following opinions:

Estrada and Colletta,

Colletta inks,

Not Estrada,

Not Colletta,

John Rosenberger,

Not Rosenberger or Colletta,

Irv Novick,

Bill Draut,

Tom Lavier sent a link about that issue that had John Rosenberger as the penciller on one story it could possibly be, but I'm pretty sure it's the other story.

So, unless DC has it on record somewhere, we'll never know. I'm keeping the name I put on it but changing the artist to "Nobody Knows"

Social/Sharing

About the Owner

	Robert Plunkett
Joined:	October 2003
Last Login:	December 2024
Country:	UNITED STATES
On CAF:	Artworks Commented On Liked Art Site Activity on CAF

Contact the Owner

Use can use a contact form to send an email to this gallery owner,
but, you must be logged in to use this feature.

Comments on this Artwork

You must be logged in to make comments.

Ray Cuthbert
Member Since 2003

Posted on 8/9/2007

The only thing that looks remotely Toth-like to me here is the girl in the floral print blouse in the second panel -- and only in that panel.

Michael Bair
Member Since 2005

Posted on 8/9/2007

well..some of the design elements & layouts..even the treatment of the details of the 1st panel is out of the "Toth" playbook, but definitely not Toth....nope not Toth....BTW..nice page.

Jeff Singh
Member Since 2004

Posted on 8/9/2007

not toth. the second last panel has a very strong toth feel to it but there isn't enough on this page to suggest toth ever touched it in layouts, pencils or inks. cool piece none the less, very nice flow.

Scott James
Member Since 2005

Posted on 8/9/2007

Nice page not Toth! :)

JOE JUSKO
Member Since 2004

Posted on 8/9/2007

Pretty sure it's Novick, not Toth. Nice page!

Will K
Member Since 2006

Posted on 10/30/2007

Kurt Schaffenberger inked by Don Heck

Mark Paten
Member Since 2004

Posted on 12/24/2007

What about the possibility of Wayne Howard as an inker for it does have a slight Wood-ish tone to it as he was around DC during that time.

William Wray
Member Since 2010

Posted on 6/7/2011

People always forget Bill Druat. It's him.

Robert Plunkett
Member Since 2003

Posted on 6/7/2011

William Wray wrote:

People always forget Bill Druat. It's him.

Thanks for the comment. An artist of some note emailed me privately some time ago and said it was Draut and made it seem like a fact and not an opinion.

All
	Rugrat Spawn 9/6/2025 5:47:00 PM
	Mark Graham 9/6/2025 5:34:00 PM
	J Murdock 9/6/2025 5:26:00 PM
	Shannon Weathers 9/6/2025 5:16:00 PM
	Dave E 9/6/2025 4:57:00 PM
View All


	Chris Johnson 9/6/2025 4:55:00 PM
	GP Bart 9/6/2025 4:33:00 PM
	Spencer McCarter 9/6/2025 4:31:00 PM
	Mike Haynes 9/6/2025 4:00:00 PM
	Richard Donnelly 9/6/2025 3:45:00 PM