Robert Minshall UNITED STATES
Member Since February 2017
286 Artworks | Watched by 0

Gallery Comments by Robert Minshall

30 Results

Saga of the Sub-Mariner #7 by Rich Buckler and Bob McLeod, Comic Art
Saga of the Sub-Mariner #7 by Rich Buckler and Bob McLeod
Owner:
commented posted on 11/13/2023

Amazing cover piece. One to be proud of. Nice !!!

Saga of the Sub-Mariner #7 by Rich Buckler and Bob McLeod, Comic Art
Saga of the Sub-Mariner #7 by Rich Buckler and Bob McLeod
Owner:
commented posted on 9/11/2023

Surprised I didn't see this before in your collection.  It's Totally Awesome! Love the series and congrats on your amazing page. Yes, Rich and Bob made an outstanding team. Thanks Marcus.

Rogue Trooper You Only Die Twice part 7 page 2, Comic Art
Rogue Trooper You Only Die Twice part 7 page 2
Owner:
commented posted on 8/19/2023

Awesome. Nice pickups. 

Green Lantern issue #28 page #22 by Mike Mckone & Andy Lanning, Comic Art
Green Lantern issue #28 page #22 by Mike Mckone & Andy Lanning
Owner:
commented posted on 8/4/2023

That is a super page! Great couple issues of reading excitement.

Red Sonya-  Frank Thorne fan art, Comic Art
Red Sonya- Frank Thorne fan art
Owner:
commented posted on 11/4/2022
F M said:

This is not Thorne's work imho. The rendering of the shadows/the inside of her cape is much too visible and laboured upon, certainly not spontaneous enough to have been drawn by a pro-artist, especially a genius like Thorne.

Hi,   Thank you for your interest in commenting on this. As I told Lee and PatrickO also,  Thank you so much for clearing up what this art is . I don't have any actual Thorne art myself, so nice to get all this feedback. Thanks again, Rob

Red Sonya-  Frank Thorne fan art, Comic Art
Red Sonya- Frank Thorne fan art
Owner:
commented posted on 11/4/2022
Patrick O. said:

Hi. I collect Thorne art and I completely agree with Mr Lee's comment above. The difference that stands out to me is that Frank was very skilled and particular with drawing contrasting curved lines. For example, the sharp curves of the ends of the cloak contrasting/ framing the longer curves of the limbs. The artist of your drawing doesn't have that same consistent line/curve control. Having said that, the spirit of the piece is there and it is very fun to see. I hope that it gets displayed prominently!

Thank you so much for you're comment.. It puts a lot of the the wondering to rest.   I do think it is a pretty cool piece, but I thought I would ask the experts an actual Frank Thorne artwork.  I knew if it was a chance of getting an answer I should post it on my gallery.  I really do appreciate you guys feedback..

Red Sonya-  Frank Thorne fan art, Comic Art
Red Sonya- Frank Thorne fan art
Owner:
commented posted on 11/4/2022
Eric L said:

looks like an amateur rendition of an image Frank used on his letterhead- https://www.comicartfans.com/GalleryPiece.asp?Piece=47040

Thank you so much for your reply .  Didn't know about the Treasury edition art. Thought somebody might know something about this . Thank you again, Rob

Fantastic Four 175, page 6, Comic Art
Fantastic Four 175, page 6
Owner:
commented posted on 7/24/2022

That IS really Awesome! As a High Evolutionary fan, I really appreciate such pages. Thanks for posting.

House of Ax 2, Comic Art
House of Ax 2
Owner:
commented posted on 6/17/2022

Pretty sweet horror page. I'm sure you have more in the drawer to share with the world,  on CAF. Thanks.

FEMFORCE 32 PAGE 1 SPLASH! , Comic Art
FEMFORCE 32 PAGE 1 SPLASH!
Owner:
commented posted on 4/5/2022
Marcus Wai said:

Great that it recaps her story and gives us a view of both Heisler and Garganta on the same image.

Thanks Dude. Powerful page! :-)

Femforce 22 pg 23 RAD!, Comic Art
Femforce 22 pg 23 RAD!
Owner:
commented posted on 12/23/2021
Eric B said:

A nice fusion of underground comix and superhero comics sensibilities. Congratulations!

Thank you so much for the Cool remark and and checking out my latest acquisitions This really reminds me of the EC  Horror stories and has  gripping  emotion of vulnerability, age,  and death that laugh at is.:-)

Femforce 22 pg 23 RAD!, Comic Art
Femforce 22 pg 23 RAD!
Owner:
commented posted on 12/23/2021
Marcus Wai said:

This is a very well designed page.  The kind that shows up on non superhero comics because they are more about narrative than constant action.  It looks like it could be a horror page with lots of symbolism and mood.  The skull and the woman who are prominently featured, convey a haunting feel that lingers in your soul.

Thanks for the awesome remarks and and I could not have I could not have said it better on this page . Really.. But it is one of those pages that just grab at you deep down..   Bill's experiences with with various genres of comics growing up  Really show in  his storytelling and He has had   Some great artists, besides himself .

Femforce 22 pg 23 RAD!, Comic Art
Femforce 22 pg 23 RAD!
Owner:
commented posted on 12/23/2021
Marcus Wai said:

This is a very well designed page.  The kind that shows up on non superhero comics because they are more about narrative than constant action.  It looks like it could be a horror page with lots of symbolism and mood.  The skull and the woman who are prominently featured, convey a haunting feel that lingers in your soul.

Thanks for the awesome remarks and and I could not have I could not have said it better on this page . Really.. But it is one of those pages that just grab at you deep down..   Bill's experiences with with various genres of comics growing up  Really show in  his storytelling and He has had   Some great artists, besides himself .

Femforce 23 Page 5 - Rad/Ms. Victory, Comic Art
Femforce 23 Page 5 - Rad/Ms. Victory
Owner:
commented posted on 11/18/2021
Marcus Wai said:

Beauty in a pill!  The fountain of youth that could make billions just with a promise on a late night infomercial.  They don't spare any effort to contrast the two ladies and their age and style.

It's been fun reading Bill and the gang's Paragon & AC Comics. He's got a great run of "cult " movies too. Thanks for all the cool input.

Saga Of The Sub Mariner #9 Page 4, Comic Art
Saga Of The Sub Mariner #9 Page 4
Owner:
commented posted on 8/6/2021

Thank you very much for the comments. I really enjoy the Submariner pages that I have. And especially from the era of time. I see you have some quite amazing pages yourself. They encompass some of the best Hulk, Submariner, and Silver Surfer. Great job!

Femforce Up-Close 7 pg 23, Comic Art
Femforce Up-Close 7 pg 23
Owner:
commented posted on 5/30/2021
Michael Armstrong said:

Nice, I have the previous page!

Thanks. Great to be able to share such great artwork.

Defenders 124 pg 6 by Don Perlin, Comic Art
Defenders 124 pg 6 by Don Perlin
Owner:
commented posted on 12/12/2020
TV kid said:

Middle right and bottom panels rock. Nice page!

Thanks very much. Being a Sub-Mariner fan I thought it very interesting when the Tribunal basically put him in his place. Wow! Don art is Awesome too.

Amazing Spider-Man #23. 3rd appearance of the Green Goblin! Spider-Man vs Green Goblin battle page!, Comic Art
Amazing Spider-Man #23. 3rd appearance of the Green Goblin! Spider-Man vs Green Goblin battle page!
Owner:
commented posted on 9/12/2020

An amazing book, but such a beautiful page of art! Steve Ditko workmanship is REALLY Amazing!

Framed - Brightest Day, Comic Art
Framed - Brightest Day
Owner:
commented posted on 5/11/2020

Nice job!

Dawnstar 2000, Comic Art
Dawnstar 2000
Owner:
commented posted on 9/25/2019

Really cool :-)

Dawnstar 2000, Comic Art
Dawnstar 2000
Owner:
commented posted on 9/25/2019

Really cool :-)

Green Lantern Series 3 Issue 50 Page 26 1st Parallax, Comic Art
Green Lantern Series 3 Issue 50 Page 26 1st Parallax
Owner:
commented posted on 9/20/2019

If you ever want to donate to Charity, I'm your charity case. LOL Love this era of Green Lantern.

ROMEO TANGHAL - DETECTIVE COMICS, Comic Art
ROMEO TANGHAL - DETECTIVE COMICS
Owner:
commented posted on 6/28/2019

I liked it so much I bought it. Thank you very much for allowing me to add this to my Collection. Rob

Age Of Apocalypse One Shot Page Featuring Magneto Wolverine & Jean Grey By Mark Brooks, Comic Art
Age Of Apocalypse One Shot Page Featuring Magneto Wolverine & Jean Grey By Mark Brooks
Owner:
commented posted on 2/17/2018

Another awesome piece of Magneto art. Congrats!

Justice League of America 141, page 5, Comic Art
Justice League of America 141, page 5
Owner:
commented posted on 2/17/2018

Awesome page!

Sub Mariner #1 Page 9, Comic Art
Sub Mariner #1 Page 9
Owner:
commented posted on 11/25/2017

Wish I knew then that it was for sale. WOW!

John Buscema Submariner #20 splash, Comic Art
John Buscema Submariner #20 splash
Owner:
commented posted on 11/3/2017

SWEET!