Paul Roach UNITED KINGDOM
Member Since April 2014
128 Artworks | Watched by 61

Defenders #15 page 9 – Magneto and the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants

Location: Defenders
Artists: Klaus Janson (Inker) ,  Sal Buscema (Layouts) ,  Klaus Janson (Finisher)

224  Views  -  45  Comments  -  20  Likes

Additional Images

Cell 1 Title/Credits

Cell 2 Cast

Cells 13-14 Nick Fury (Life Model Decoy)

Cell 16 Team flying

Cell 19 Scorpio attacks

Cell 20 Hulk SMASH puny Scorpio
Artwork Details
Location: Defenders
Title: Defenders #15 page 9 – Magneto and the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants
Artist:  Klaus Janson (Inker) ,  Sal Buscema (Layouts) ,  Klaus Janson (Finisher)
Media Type: Pen and Ink
Art Type: Interior Page
For Sale Status: NFS
Views: 224
Likes on CAF: 20
Favorited on CAF: 1
Comments: 45
Added to Site: 2/17/2026

Share This Artwork
Description
This is a special page for me, as this is from one of the earliest US comics I read. My brother bought this one while we were on a summer holiday, back in 1974. We both pored over every panel. I recall being transfixed by Nighthawk (who Hulk called ‘birdnose’) and Valkyrie. This was the second issue on which Klaus inked over Sal (the first was #13), and supposedly the first he did over Sal’s layouts – although it often looked as though Sal’s layouts could be fairly detailed. For me, that was one of the greatest partnerships in comics.

Nighthawk got his classic costume in this issue. Professor X has contacted Stephen Strange to help him defeat Magneto, but they are defeated by the Brotherhood of Evil mutants – and captured, as seen on this page. The creature in the giant glass jar is Alpha, the Ultimate Mutant, whom Magneto seeks to awaken.

Although we weren’t to get another issue of the title until #33, the characters were firmly lodged in my mind as the ultimate superhero team. So much so, that they became the focus of an over-ambitious attempt to make a Defenders cartoon in 1977 (when I was 10). On gaining access to our father’s Super-8 Cine Camera, ideal for stop motion projects, and some animation paper and cell peg boards, my brother and I decided that we would make some cartoons. David decided on a relatively manageable project – a short sequence of a hedgehog moving slightly. I decided on a one hour animated feature film on the Defenders, entitled “Who Remembers Scorpio?”. It was so ambitious that I had to co-opt my brother (age 12) into its (unfinished) creation.

Neither cartoon was ever filmed. However, I still have everything that was produced. It comprises a large number of backgrounds, coloured in felt tip pen, and some separate, slightly articulated character drawings that would be moved in between stop motion shots. I have attached some additional scans of the animation elements, for gentle mocking. (And in the hope that it persuades Peter Sullivan to upload some of his childhood creations.)

About The Owner

Thank You For Supporting CAF!
Paul Roach
Badges: Premium Gallery Owner
Member Since: April 2014
Last Login: April 2026
Country: UNITED KINGDOM
On CAF:
Paul's Want List
Artworks Commented On
Liked Art
Site Activity
Contact Paul Roach

Login or register for an account to email the owner of this artwork.

Comments on this Artwork

You must be logged in to make comments.
Daniele Carrabba Member Since 2018
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Fantastic!!

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
Posted On 2/18/2026

Daniele Carrabba wrote:
"  Fantastic!!
 "

Thanks, Daniele - I'm glad you like it!

Toni S Member Since 2019
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Your unfinished work should come to the MCU definetely... I bet you, it probably would be better than some of the films released. This page is simply insane to me. Two of my all time favourite characters in the same page. I always love the pages were it is possible to see Magneto's eyes behind his helmet.

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
Posted On 2/18/2026

Toni S wrote:
"  Your unfinished work should come to the MCU definetely... I bet you, it probably would be better than some of the films released. This page is simply insane to me. Two of my all time favourite characters in the same page. I always love the pages were it is possible to see Magneto's eyes behind his helmet.
 "

Thanks, Toni. I think there may need to be some small improvements to the production value first, but a pitch for a Defenders movie is long overdue. And yes, Sal has done the evil eyes behind the helment to master-criminal-perfection.

Rick W Member Since 2017
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Your gallery is full of surprises! Fantastic page!

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
1    
Posted On 2/18/2026

Rick W wrote:
"  Your gallery is full of surprises! Fantastic page!
 "

Thanks, Rick. I think the cupboards in my house are full of surprises as well, and many of them may not be welcome on CAF. But still they come.

Steve Day Vich Member Since 2007
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Pretty good page even if it doesn't have The Headmen.

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
Posted On 2/17/2026

Steve Day Vich wrote:
"  Pretty good page even if it doesn't have The Headmen.
 "

Ha ha! OK, I'll put up some Headmen pages very soon. I should have planned a Headmen cartoon as well, but I'm not sure that I had the writing range for horror at that age.

Steve Day Vich Member Since 2007
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Paul Roach wrote:
"  Ha ha! OK, I'll put up some Headmen pages very soon. I should have planned a Headmen cartoon as well, but I'm not sure that I had the writing range for horror at that age.
 "

Be prepared for me to bother you about them on a daily basis.

James S Member Since 2017
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Ohhhh, the Defenders going against a REAL villian!

Jason Hussa Member Since 2017
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

There was something-SO- special about this issue, right?  I have a -very- distinct memory of a classmate bringing this issue into school when I was about 8.  At that time, when I saw #15 for the first time, it was an old "back issue".  I remember lobbying my parents pretty hard for a subscription to The Defenders when I must have been -SIX- (which is insane, but I remember the first issue I received was #45, so...?), and I loved it because the lineup of heroes was so WIERD.  But #15 wasn't one I had seen before.  The cover grabbed me, of course (just as it should have), and I remember thinking that, as an undisputed authority on the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants (seeing as how I had just picked up Amazing Adventures #s 10 & 11 -which reprinted most of X-Men #s 4 & 5 :) ), I really should check this one out, too...  And I remember it as being WEIRD! :)  This is a great page from it.  I love the wireframe of all our heroes, even as Magneto fully embraces his "Dark Helmet" phase.  Seeing this lovely page now, the obvious killer is that fantastic third panel with the worm's eye POV (just as Magneto likes it) and the incredible textures and arcing, sparking electricity given to the tubed figure via the white paint and brushstrokes...  SO cool!  But I guess the big takeaway here, Paul, is... seriously, who lets their kid subscribe to Defenders at SIX?!? ;) GREAT page, sir!  Congrats!

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
1    
Posted On 2/20/2026

Jason Hussa wrote:
"  There was something-SO- special about this issue, right?  I have a -very- distinct memory of a classmate bringing this issue into school when I was about 8.  At that time, when I saw #15 for the first time, it was an old "back issue".  I remember lobbying my parents pretty hard for a subscription to The Defenders when I must have been -SIX- (which is insane, but I remember the first issue I received was #45, so...?), and I loved it because the lineup of heroes was so WIERD.  But #15 wasn't one I had seen before.  The cover grabbed me, of course (just as it should have), and I remember thinking that, as an undisputed authority on the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants (seeing as how I had just picked up Amazing Adventures #s 10 & 11 -which reprinted most of X-Men #s 4 & 5 :) ), I really should check this one out, too...  And I remember it as being WEIRD! :)  This is a great page from it.  I love the wireframe of all our heroes, even as Magneto fully embraces his "Dark Helmet" phase.  Seeing this lovely page now, the obvious killer is that fantastic third panel with the worm's eye POV (just as Magneto likes it) and the incredible textures and arcing, sparking electricity given to the tubed figure via the white paint and brushstrokes...  SO cool!  But I guess the big takeaway here, Paul, is... seriously, who lets their kid subscribe to Defenders at SIX?!? ;) GREAT page, sir!  Congrats!
 "

Wow, yes, a subscription to Defenders at that age is pretty unusual :-o. But kudos to your parents. You're right about the aggrandising view of Magneto, looking down on his subjects. Thanks, Jason!

Jason Hussa Member Since 2017
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

(Also, I can say without doubt or hesitation that I was absolutely -THE- target audience for your animated Defenders classic.  Should you ever decide to finish it up (any chance for a Kickstarter or GoFundMe?) please consider my name added to your email notification list!! :) Wish our paths had crossed back then!  Too, too cool, Paul!)

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
1    
Posted On 2/20/2026

Jason Hussa wrote:
"  (Also, I can say without doubt or hesitation that I was absolutely -THE- target audience for your animated Defenders classic.  Should you ever decide to finish it up (any chance for a Kickstarter or GoFundMe?) please consider my name added to your email notification list!! :) Wish our paths had crossed back then!  Too, too cool, Paul!)
 "

Ha ha! I'm not sure how much I'd raise, but I'm keeping my fingers crossed for a Gerber-based MCU Defenders movie with Nebulon and the Headmen. I think I may be crossing those fingers for a long time yet. Would have been good to have met back then, yes! We could have compared issues of Defenders in our collections!

Patrick R Member Since 2017
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Fun to see your childhood animation ambition Paul. Thanks for posting. 

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
Posted On 2/18/2026

Patrick R wrote:
"  Fun to see your childhood animation ambition Paul. Thanks for posting. 
 "

Thanks, Patrick. I'm sure I'll be able to squeeze in a few more images of  my (over) ambition. :-o

Danny Kiihnl Member Since 2022
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

thats a great defenders page but the story and pictures of your cartoon dream are my favorite thing about your post

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
Posted On 2/20/2026

Danny Kiihnl wrote:
"  thats a great defenders page but the story and pictures of your cartoon dream are my favorite thing about your post
 "

Thanks, Danny. It was fun to relive that dream.

Carlo M Member Since 2006
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

I used to own this page and am so glad it went to a good home.  And BTW the Skorpio storyline was so good.  Excellent choice you made there!

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
Posted On 2/23/2026

Carlo M wrote:
"  I used to own this page and am so glad it went to a good home.  And BTW the Skorpio storyline was so good.  Excellent choice you made there!
 "

Thanks, Carlo. I think I have a few that passed through your collection, so do please let me know when that happens. It's always interesting to know who owned the pages before me.

Kavi H Member Since 2018
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Brilliant Defenders/BOEM/Magneto page, love how menacing Magneto looks in that final panel. Congrats on a page from an issue very important to you and your brother! Who Remembers Scorpio looked like a great creative outlet for you young lads :)

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
1    
Posted On 2/23/2026

Kavi H wrote:
"  Brilliant Defenders/BOEM/Magneto page, love how menacing Magneto looks in that final panel. Congrats on a page from an issue very important to you and your brother! Who Remembers Scorpio looked like a great creative outlet for you young lads :)
 "

Ha ha! Thanks, Kavi. Well, we're not so young now, of course. But we both had fun seeing the page and remembering reading the comic.

J. Sid Member Since 2004
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Those cells are awesome. (Page ain't half bad either!)

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
Posted On 2/19/2026

J. Sid wrote:
"  Those cells are awesome. (Page ain't half bad either!)
 "

Thanks! We had a lot of fun doing them, and it was a nice surprise to stumble across them again.

Miki Annamanthadoo Member Since 2003
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

A great classic Defenders page!  Magneto looks truly villainous in that last panel!

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
Posted On 2/23/2026

Miki Annamanthadoo wrote:
"  A great classic Defenders page!  Magneto looks truly villainous in that last panel!
 "

Yes, it's a great sneer from Magneto. Thanks, Miki!

Dan F Member Since 2004
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

That is a special page!

Nils E Member Since 2014
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

There was something special about the Defenders, the non-square Avengers, with a twist of mystic.

alessandro gentili Member Since 2011
1    
Posted On 2/17/2026

Classic Defenders page ... great ! Also, Janson inks are perfect on Sal .

Love it ! 

Marcus Wai Member Since 2005
1    
Posted On 2/18/2026

This was the time when X-Men went on their reprints and we get the X-Men related characters pop up in many titles.  Having Magneto here strengthened his character and kept him in the spotlight as a major villain in the entire Marvel Universe!  No matter what title, Magneto sure likes to talk about his evil plans!

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
1    
Posted On 2/19/2026

Marcus Wai wrote:
"  This was the time when X-Men went on their reprints and we get the X-Men related characters pop up in many titles.  Having Magneto here strengthened his character and kept him in the spotlight as a major villain in the entire Marvel Universe!  No matter what title, Magneto sure likes to talk about his evil plans!
 "

Yes, it was a strange time for the X-Men, and every appearance seemed like a special event. Not now. You 're just tripping over X-Men absolutely everywhere now. They're all over the place!

West Stephan Member Since 2007
1    
Posted On 2/18/2026

Love Magneto pages. Such a cool piece!

Al Simpleton Member Since 2013
1    
Posted On 2/19/2026

First, this page is splendid! The Sal Buscema/Klaus Janson team worked wonders! And, yes, this helmet evil stare counts among the best Magneto shots ever, ranking next to Kirby's X-Men 1 and Byrne's X-Men 112...

Second, I also think your Defenders animation film deserves a chance to  get on the big screen! The Scorpio stroryline, with all its hoops and holes, leaves ample opportunities for good stories... and, with the Defenders in it, it's still a sure-fire smash hit! 
 

Being from the same generation, I perfectly understand the drive that sparkled your creativity and the urge to get more of these characters and stories... I really admire the fact that you want all the way to plan an animated film! On my side, I resorted to creating cut-outs to play with (all this long before action figures...) and I tried to do my own comic stories, which, due to my very limited talent and despite some heavy swiping, never reached completion...

Oh, well... Thanks for sharing!

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
1    
Posted On 3/7/2026

Al Simpleton wrote:
"  First, this page is splendid! The Sal Buscema/Klaus Janson team worked wonders! And, yes, this helmet evil stare counts among the best Magneto shots ever, ranking next to Kirby's X-Men 1 and Byrne's X-Men 112...
Second, I also think your Defenders animation film deserves a chance to  get on the big screen! The Scorpio stroryline, with all its hoops and holes, leaves ample opportunities for good stories... and, with the Defenders in it, it's still a sure-fire smash hit! 
 
Being from the same generation, I perfectly understand the drive that sparkled your creativity and the urge to get more of these characters and stories... I really admire the fact that you want all the way to plan an animated film! On my side, I resorted to creating cut-outs to play with (all this long before action figures...) and I tried to do my own comic stories, which, due to my very limited talent and despite some heavy swiping, never reached completion...
Oh, well... Thanks for sharing!
 "

Wow, thanks Al! I'm so pleased that you rate the Magneto stare shot so highly. And I'm grateful for the kind words on the animation effort. The cut outs sound great - do you still have any to put up? Comics certainly did spark a lot of creativity back then.

Al Simpleton Member Since 2013
1    
Posted On 3/9/2026

Paul Roach wrote:
"  Wow, thanks Al! I'm so pleased that you rate the Magneto stare shot so highly. And I'm grateful for the kind words on the animation effort. The cut outs sound great - do you still have any to put up? Comics certainly did spark a lot of creativity back then.
 "

Thanks Paul for the suggestion! I'll take some time to do some archeology and dig deep into my very dusty archives just to see if some of these cut-outs have survived! It could be fun...

Mario Losada Member Since 2011
1    
Posted On 2/23/2026

I remember perfectly the first issues of The Defenders. A winner

Bill Thomson Member Since 2004
1    
Posted On 2/24/2026

GREAT PAGE!!! Janson's inks definitely gave Sal's art a much more realistic look. They were a great pairing, but I think Sal's art looked great with most inkers because his draftsmanship and story-telling were so outstanding! I love the variety of panels on this beautiful page... high perspectives, low perspectives, close-ups... and the absence of solid blacks in the force field was extremely effective, differentiating that space from the outside!

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
Posted On 3/7/2026

Bill Thomson wrote:
"  GREAT PAGE!!! Janson's inks definitely gave Sal's art a much more realistic look. They were a great pairing, but I think Sal's art looked great with most inkers because his draftsmanship and story-telling were so outstanding! I love the variety of panels on this beautiful page... high perspectives, low perspectives, close-ups... and the absence of solid blacks in the force field was extremely effective, differentiating that space from the outside!
 "

Thanks, Bill! And I very much agree on Sal's storytelling ability and his variety of panel compositions on this page. It really looked like they were both having a lot of fun on this issue.

Red Raven Member Since 2012
1    
Posted On 2/24/2026

Classic pièce évil mutants - Bravo !!

Mark Levy Member Since 2004
1    
Posted On 2/25/2026

Ah, sweet sorrow - I owned this one too briefly (11/06 to 8/08) - always loved that last panel!

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
1    
Posted On 3/7/2026

Mark Levy wrote:
"  Ah, sweet sorrow - I owned this one too briefly (11/06 to 8/08) - always loved that last panel!
 "

Thanks, Mark. I'm always interested to know who owned a page before me, and perhaps that will happen again when I put up some more!

M L Member Since 2015
1    
Posted On 2/26/2026

What's particularly striking to me is how different this is from the other page you posted. Janson was able to get away from the talking heads and the variety of line weights and angles is really great. 

Michael  McIsaac Member Since 2020
1    
Posted On 3/6/2026

Now that's what I call an unambiguously evil Magneto.  All that he's missing is a mustache to twirl.

That's great that you tried to do your own film, and even better that you still have the work you created for it.  It must bring back fun memories whenever you look at them.

Paul Roach Member Since 2014
1    
Posted On 3/7/2026

Michael McIsaac wrote:
"  Now that's what I call an unambiguously evil Magneto.  All that he's missing is a mustache to twirl.
That's great that you tried to do your own film, and even better that you still have the work you created for it.  It must bring back fun memories whenever you look at them.
 "

Ha ha! Yes, a Dick Dastardly mustache would have been great. Thanks Michael, and yes you're right - it did bring back a lot of happy memories when I stumbled across the artwork for the 'cartoon'!

K Gearon Member Since 2011
1    
Posted On 4/6/2026

One of the most evil grins we seen on Mags!  Congrats!

You must be logged in to make comments.