Al Simpleton wrote:
" I also have to admit it took me a while to adjust to seeing Frank Robbins' art at Marvel... I did love his comic strip work, especially Johnny Hazard that I found firmly grounded in the Milton Caniff tradition. I also liked it a lot when he joined DC to provide some hard-boiled edged visuals to Batman and the Shadow (this, after years of providing high-quality scenarios for the Caped Crusader - worth checking!). But the gaudy colors of the standard Marvel crew seemed to me a little bit awkward for his style. But, I learned to appreciate it, especially his dynamics on figures that I still find totally cartoonish (your page has a lot of this!), but it fits in so well with the spirit of the title that it makes for a great combination! And, yet, I wonder what he could have done with a grittier character like the Punisher, or Frank Miller's version of Daredevil...
"
It's such a common thing to hear about Robbins - he really seemed to divide people on some of his superhero work, but was easier to appreciate in adulthood. Interesting that you liked his DC work at the time. His figures could certainly be very expressive. I guess for me, some of the same things could be said about Andru on Spider-Man - but I liked Andru at the time too. Thanks for the detailed comments - I really appreciate them, Al!