Log In Register
Timothy Finney JAPAN
Member Since August 2006
247 Artworks | Watched by 83

The Tragical Comedy or Comical Tragedy of Mr. Punch page 47 by Dave McKean

Location: 80s & Up Vertigo
Artists: Dave McKean (All) ,  Neil Gaimen (Writer)

3172  Views  -  20  Comments  -  2  Likes

Additional Images

Cover

Published page
Artwork Details
Location: 80s & Up Vertigo
Title: The Tragical Comedy or Comical Tragedy of Mr. Punch page 47 by Dave McKean*
Artist:  Dave McKean (All) ,  Neil Gaimen (Writer)
Media Type: Pen and Ink
Art Type: Interior Page
For Sale Status:
Views: 3172
Likes on CAF: 2
Comments: 20
Added to Site: 11/1/2014

Share This Artwork
Description
Childhood memories are often unreliable and fractured and, even when accurate, subject to revision as we grow older and understand things from adult perspectives. Like the main character in Mr. Punch, I have a tendency to try and bury my more unpleasant ones, but they are still located in the deep recesses of my mind, and, as in Mr. Punch, when given certain stimuli, they can come back to haunt me.

No, to my knowledge, there are no Punch and Judy shows at a seedy seaside arcade, pregnant mermaids or (possible) murders hidden in my family closet. However, I could still identify with the narrator's plight.

Of course, Dave McKean's art plays a great role in keeping this book alive in my memory. It was a stunning display of line art, photography and other odd bits and (sorry, Arkham Asylum), in my opinion, it is probably his sequential comic's masterpiece. So, when I saw Marc Mokken had some pages from this graphic novel available, I really wanted to acquire one of them.

One thing that surprised me, however, was seeing that the pages he had were all ink art rather than being fully painted or mixed media pieces. According to Marc, McKean finished much of the art on a computer, so the black and white pages he had were the actual original art for the story. And of all the pages he had, this is the one that really called out to me. Nope, Mr. Punch is not on this page, but the mysterious "Professor" (the Punch and Judy Man himself), the narrator's childhood persona, Toby the dog, an incomplete bit of text and, of course, unspoken secrets are, and, while this page is a bit outside my usual collecting habits, I could not be happier.

About The Owner

Member Since: August 2006
Last Login: July 2026
Country: JAPAN
On CAF:
Timothy's Want List
Artworks Commented On
Liked Art
Site Activity
Contact Timothy Finney

Login or register for an account to email the owner of this artwork.

Comments on this Artwork

You must be logged in to make comments.
Eric Seffinga Member Since 2005
Posted On 11/1/2014

Been eyeballing this one for months too. Good call, great series and a great piece. Congrats.
Felix  Lu Member Since 2005
Posted On 11/1/2014

Have never read this story, but now I really want to. Congrats, Tim!
Jeff Singh Member Since 2004
Posted On 11/1/2014

Great piece of comic art that stands up as fine art as well.
Chris K. Member Since 2008
Posted On 11/1/2014

A gorgeous piece of art!
Dimitrios Z Member Since 2011
Posted On 11/1/2014

Great story and description. Congrats bud!
Aidan (Re-Legion ) Lacy Member Since 2005
Posted On 11/1/2014

It has a cool and edgy " Edgar Allan Poe " vibe about it
Timothy Finney Member Since 2006
Posted On 11/1/2014

Aidan (Re-Legion ) Lacy wrote:
" It has a cool and edgy " Edgar Allan Poe " vibe about it  "
Hmm. You know, I never thought of that before, but yes, now that I've contemplated it, I can see where you are coming from. First, of course, is the almost Gothic aesthetic of its gloomy, yet dream-like, atmosphere with a narrator trapped in a claustrophobic setting (in this case, his own memories as opposed to a haunted mansion) at the mercy of buried (or bricked up, perhaps) mysteries. And the protagonist has many of the classic qualities of Poe's often unnamed narrators who find themselves in situations both outside of their control and understanding (the narrator of "The Fall of the House of Usher" for instance). Also in Usher, now that I think about it, Poe even made allusions to poems that both parallel and predict the plot, much the way Gaiman and McKean use the Punch and Judy show. Why, if I were still in college, I might have me the makings of a new research paper.
G. C. Member Since 2006
Posted On 11/1/2014

Nice one Timothy ! Congrats !!
Brian Jones Member Since 2005
Posted On 11/1/2014

Fantastic!
Sean Clarke Member Since 2005
Posted On 11/2/2014

I never noticed until looking at your page, but McKean is rocking a Bernie Krigstein influence in parts of this story. Wonderful and expressive art... a fine example of what comics can be!
Timothy Finney Member Since 2006
Posted On 11/2/2014

Sean Clarke wrote:
" I never noticed until looking at your page, but McKean is rocking a Bernie Krigstein influence in parts of this story. Wonderful and expressive art... a fine example of what comics can be!  "
This is what I like about CAF. I have not seen/read enough of Krigstein's work to internalize it, but a quick google search allowed me to easily see some of the similarities in style these artists share. Thanks for the insight.
Shelton  Bryant Member Since 2005
Posted On 11/3/2014

Brilliant!!!!Luv the final panels and Text!!!!!
Patrick  Brooks Member Since 2008
Posted On 11/3/2014

McKean's work is nothing short of genius. Love the lines and mood of this piece. Congrats, Tim. It's a beauty.
M,B The collector Member Since 2008
Posted On 11/3/2014

preciosa pagina !!!! felicitaciones !!!!!!!!
Fabio C. Member Since 2005
Posted On 11/3/2014

terrific page!
Mario Rhodanos Member Since 2004
Posted On 11/5/2014

woooooooooooooooooow
J L Member Since 2005
Posted On 11/5/2014

Really great write up Tim which makes me want to read this story. Congrats on finding a page that means a lot to you. Very cool art too!!!!
Alex B Member Since 2008
Posted On 11/13/2014

Congrats on scoring THE page ! Great story and perfect art !
Suat Tong Ng Member Since 2009
Posted On 11/25/2014

Big congrats on acquiring this - your biggest buy in some time? I was also surprised to see that this was the "true" nature of the OA (as opposed to the seemingly mixed media presentation of the comic).
max Rugers Member Since 2004
Posted On 1/8/2015

stunning page from a amazing story!!
You must be logged in to make comments.